Key points:
- The unravelling of Silicon Valley Bank is a great exemplar of the problems in the US banking system.
- Antipodes sees more pain ahead, but it won’t be limited to banks.
- The European banking system is not the same as the US. Antipodes’ portfolio holding UniCredit is a great example.
- The market bets Fed rate cuts are imminent. The pivot is coming but that won’t necessarily mark the market bottom.
- The range of outcomes is wide, but opportunities exist – see how Antipodes is positioned in this current environment.
Almost 15 years to the day of the Bear Stearns collapse, the demise of Silicon Valley Bank marked the largest bank failure since the 2008 financial crisis.
Much has been written about the unravelling of Silicon Valley Bank (SIVB), so we’ll keep this bit punchy.
SIVB is a single industry bank (it reportedly banked around half of all venture capital backed start-ups in the US), with a dependence on corporate deposits and as a result a disproportionately high degree of uninsured deposits (>$250,000).
A tech slowdown saw customers withdraw deposits to support their own businesses, but these short-term deposits had been invested in much longer dated Mortgage-Backed Securities.
This is a relatively extreme example of asset liability duration mismatch.
These securities were predominantly classified as long-term assets – or held to maturity – which meant SIVB was not required to mark to market the value of these assets per the current regulation, nor recognise the losses in capital. Higher interest rates significantly eroded the value of these securities, and any forced sale of these assets to meet continued deposit withdrawals would have wiped out SIVB’s equity.
This is a just brief overview of SIVB’s demise, but it illustrates what is at the core of the current crisis.
So, how did we get here?
The failure of SIVB is in part a failure of the regulatory framework; regional banks should not have been exempt from mark to market rules on securities portfolios nor been allowed to hold such a large proportion of their liquidity in long duration assets.
SIVB is not alone. There are other banks with material unrealised losses on bond portfolios and a large proportion of funding from uninsured deposits. They’re predominantly in the longer tail of regional and community banks that sit outside the top 20 banks, and account for 40% of system deposits. That doesn’t mean they are all insolvent or will face deposit runs – they won’t, but investors should continue to monitor the situation closely.
The structure of the US banking system is also at the heart of the current crisis – it’s very fragmented.
It has a deep money market which creates competition for deposits, a high degree of fixed-rate lending (driven by mortgages) which can exacerbate the asset-liability mismatch, and corporate lending faces significant competition from the bond market.
With bank capital ratios overstated due to unrealised losses on bond portfolios, the US banking system is shifting from one of excess capital which bolstered shareholder returns via buybacks and dividends, to potentially needing to raise capital.
What’s to come
Competition for deposits is already increasing, and we are seeing some evidence of deposits leaving the system for higher yielding cash management accounts.
So, the key implications are pressure on bank profitability as deposits re-price, overstated capital ratios due to unrealised losses on bond portfolios, and tighter regulation and/or a focus on liquidity which could impact credit creation.
A higher cost of funding would be manageable if most lending was at variable rates, as it is in most banking markets, but in the US almost 60% of assets (loans and bonds) are fixed rate. As the cost of deposits rise, US banks are unable to reprice loans or bond portfolios fast enough, resulting in pressure on net interest margins and bank profitability. Our simple analysis suggests that if deposit costs rose 100bp across the system, return on equity would fall from 12.5% to 8.3%, a 33% reduction.
Regional banks are essential.
They account for nearly 40% of total US bank credit, often directed towards small and medium sized businesses which are critical to the economy. Even if regulation isn’t tightened, risk management and liquidity will become the focus which could impact credit creation and in turn the US economy.
Some sectors have an even greater dependence on regional banks. For example, on the Antipodes definition of a regional bank (less than $100b in assets), regional banks account for a whopping 70% of bank Commercial Real Estate (CRE) lending and almost 40% of total CRE debt funding. This is a sector that is already under stress with high private market leverage, rising rates with a reliance on short term variable funding and falling occupancy. And now the banks they rely on for that funding and refinancing are under pressure. Since most debt is only recourse to the property, in negative equity situations the owners are simply walking away.
The solution is to cut rates
We argued conditions were already too tight at the end of 2022 due to a contraction in money supply from QT, and recent events tighten the screws further. The policy rate in the US was close to 0% just one year ago versus 5% today – the US has seen one of the sharpest rate hiking cycles in history. Given that monetary policy impacts with a lag, the full effect of recent rate hikes will likely only be felt in 2024.
The recent rate hike will likely represent the peak of the tightening cycle as the contraction in money supply coupled with a credit crunch will likely result in inflation falling and unemployment rising faster than the market anticipates.
Hence, we agree a Fed pivot is coming and recent events have brought the timeline forward. The more relevant question is whether it represents a pre-emptive “positive pivot”, with the Fed acknowledging its error of setting policy using the rear-view mirror and cutting rates and/or reversing QT now, or a lagging “negative pivot” with the Fed cutting rates later to fight the recessionary impacts of its super aggressive tightness. Our base case is the latter.
The labour market has been slow to loosen in the US and pressure on wages remains elevated. Whilst cracks are appearing in the manufacturing and construction sector, the economy remains relatively resilient, supported by the services sector and household that has been shielded from higher rates thanks to fixed rate mortgages.
The Fed will find itself in a difficult dilemma if core services inflation remains uncomfortably high.
Not all global banks are equal
Europe’s banking system is significantly different when compared to the US, and we think herein lies some opportunity for astute investors.
- European banks have a dominant share of savings and lending, hence smaller bond portfolios.
- Deposits are less likely to leave the system and competition for deposits is relatively benign.
- They have a better asset-liability match due to a larger mix of floating rate loans, meaning higher cash rates can be passed on to depositors and borrowers, protecting net interest margins.
And importantly, European regulators have been stricter since the 2008 financial crisis and subsequent European sovereign debt crisis. This led to higher capital requirements and more conservative lending practises. Capital ratios are cleaner as they include mark to market losses on any securities.
Our Portfolio holding UniCredit is a great illustration of this.
It has a core tier 1 capital ratio of 16% – which could be double the average US bank on a mark to market basis – implying 30% of current market cap in excess capital. The company is priced at 4x earnings and 0.5x book with a payout yield of 20%, and a capital management plan which could see 80% of the market cap returned to shareholders over the next four years.
The Antipodes global portfolios have been underweight US banks and we remain comfortable with our exposure to European banks.
More on our broader portfolio positioning
We are relatively defensively positioned in this current environment particularly in our developed market exposure given the threat of financial instability and recession for example via our healthcare cluster (e.g. Sanofi, Merck), attractively priced staples (e.g. Diageo, Heineken) and tech platforms (e.g. Meta, SAP, Oracle, Microsoft) and tail risk hedges (gold equities, Yen). We remain underweight Western discretionary/domestic cyclicals.
The macro backdrop in the US/West is akin to the 70s/80s where greater volatility around policy drove greater volatility in the economic cycle, which weighed on equity multiples. Remarkably analyst forecasts still imply US earnings will remain relatively flat on a year-on-year basis but using prior recessions as a guide, earnings in the US could fall at least another 10-15%. This would lift current valuations from 18.5x forward earnings to c. 21x, a meaningful premium to history.
We are comfortable taking cyclical exposure via beneficiaries of new investment cycles around decarbonisation, onshoring and infrastructure – some of which will be tomorrow’s secular winners (e.g. Siemens Energy, TotalEnergies).
Finally, with China reopening and emerging from recession, it is in a very different part of the economic and policy cycle relative to the West, and accumulated household savings can provide additional support to activity. China has already been through an earnings downgrade cycle and valuations have fallen to 12x earnings. Our focus is domestic out-of-home services recovery and emerging multinationals (e.g. Baidu, Midea).
Whilst we are positioned for the outcome where markets do not bottom until the earnings downgrade cycle matures and the Fed is well into the cutting cycle, it is important to acknowledge that in a post-COVID world of fiscal activism, the range of outcomes remains wide. We must always consider the bullish soft landing scenario and we retain a flexible mindset in the face of incoming data.
If you like to hear more analysis from our investment team on the banking crisis, you can listen to discussion on the topic between Alison Savas (Investment Director) and James Rodda (Portfolio Manager) in our latest podcast episode.
By the Antipodes Investment Team


