Antipodes Partners awarded

2026 Fund Manager of the Year, Australia

Morningstar Awards 2026 © Morningstar, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

The Valuation Blind Spot in Climate Investing

Steel electricity transmission towers stretch across the horizon at sunset, with digitally enhanced glowing blue lines representing energy flow through the power grid.
Download PDF >

A pragmatic value approach to the Net Zero transition

At Antipodes, value investing means paying the right price for growth and resilience. We apply this philosophy to climate investing by focusing on how the transition to Net Zero affects corporate cashflows over time.

Climate change is a powerful structural force. Achieving Net Zero by 2050 will require trillions of dollars of investment across energy, agriculture, industry, and infrastructure. This creates both risks and opportunities for companies operating across global supply chains.

Our goal is to identify where markets are mispricing those risks and opportunities, and to invest accordingly.

Why traditional climate investing falls short

Many investors rely heavily on reported emissions to label companies as “good” or “bad” from a climate perspective. Others pursue thematic strategies by investing in renewable energy, hydrogen, or other climate solutions without sufficient regard for price, risk, or business quality.

While well intentioned, these approaches have structural weaknesses.

Emissions-based exclusions often fail to reflect economic reality. They can penalise companies with high current emissions that are actively transitioning while rewarding those with superficially low emissions but little real-world impact. In many cases, excluding high emitters can have little impact in reducing global emissions and can restrict the flow of capital needed to fund the transition. Moreover, exclusion eliminates investor influence: without ownership, we forfeit our seat at the table and our ability to engage management on decarbonisation strategy.

Thematic investing has its own challenges. The surge in climate-themed investments during 2020–2021 led to inflated valuations, poor capital discipline, and disappointing outcomes when conditions changed. Simply providing a “green” product or service does not guarantee sustainable returns or successful delivery of transition outcomes.

The Antipodes Climate Delta Strategy was launched to offer a pragmatic, value-driven approach to transition investing, one that focuses on intrinsic value, capital allocation, and the physical realities of the energy transition.

Understanding supply chains in transition

Rather than focusing solely on emissions reporting, the Climate Delta Strategy examines companies through the lens of supply chains in transition. These are industries and processes that must physically change to move the global economy onto a Net Zero pathway.

We categorise climate impact into the following:

Transition opportunity – companies that enable these outcomes create real transition value

Activity type

Definition

Examples

1. Abatement

Replacing/modifying an existing GHG emitter supply chain with an alternative, compatible with Net Zero by 2050

  • Solar/wind energy
  • Battery electric vehicles 
  • Fossil-based carbon capture & storage 

2. Efficiency

Delivering meaningful levels of efficiency against competing products and/or installed base 

  • Insulation
  • Material reuse
  • Energy efficiency (e.g. HVAC, hard-to-measure industrial energy efficiency)

3. Removal

Capturing and neutralising GHG already contained in the atmosphere

  • Sustainable forestry
  • Ambient air carbon capture & storage
  • Biomethane pyrolysis

 

Transition risk – companies whose cashflows depend on emissions-intensive processes face transition risk

Activity type

Definition

Examples

  1. GHG emissions
  • Release GHG into the atmosphere 
  • Fossil fuel use
  • Land-use and forestry
  • Agriculture, livestock and waste

 

Measuring climate impact through intrinsic value

A major challenge in transition investing is the lack of consistent metrics for valuing climate impact. 

To address this, Antipodes developed a proprietary methodology that integrates climate analysis directly into intrinsic valuation.

We break companies into business segments and classify each segment as:

  • Transition Opportunity (T.O.): activities that support abatement, efficiency, or removal
  • Transition Risk (T.R.): activities exposed to long-term decline as the transition progresses
  • Other: activities with no direct transition linkage

From this, we calculate a Transition Divergency Score (TDS), which measures how much of a company’s intrinsic value is exposed to opportunity versus risk. Over time, we expect these two forces to diverge as the transition accelerates.

This forward-looking approach differs fundamentally from emissions-based frameworks. Instead of asking where emissions sit today, we ask which future cashflows depend on emissions continuing, and which depend on emissions falling.

 

Interpreting the score

Case study: RWE AG versus Ørsted A/S

Companies RWE and Ørsted are examples that highlight why valuation discipline matters in climate investing.

Many investors screen out RWE due to its high reported emissions. Yet RWE has transformed itself from a traditional utility into one of the world’s largest renewable energy developers. Today, the majority of its intrinsic value comes from transition-aligned assets, despite the company still appearing highly emissions-intensive on standard carbon metrics.

Because many investors exclude RWE, its shares trade at a discount, creating an opportunity for long-term investors who recognise the company’s transition progress and capital discipline.

Ørsted, by contrast, became a favourite among thematic ESG investors during the renewable energy boom. Despite strong climate credentials, aggressive growth plans and rising costs eroded shareholder value. Several large projects failed to generate returns above their cost of capital.

The lesson is clear: climate alignment alone does not guarantee investment success. Valuation, execution, and capital allocation remain critical.

Why mispricing matters for the transition

When markets undervalue companies that are genuinely enabling the transition, capital becomes more expensive, slowing progress toward Net Zero. Fairer valuations help unlock funding for further investment and provide clearer signals to policymakers about which transition pathways are economically viable.

The Climate Delta Strategy seeks to allocate capital where transition-enabling intrinsic value is undervalued, supporting both long-term returns and real-world outcomes.

Stewardship and a just transition

Active stewardship is central to the Climate Delta responsible investment strategy. Antipodes engages with companies on governance, capital allocation, and the social dimensions of the transition, including workforce impacts and community outcomes.

A successful energy transition must be a just transition. Managing workforce change, maintaining energy security, and supporting affected regions are essential for long-term social and political sustainability.

A practical pathway for climate-aware investors

The Climate Delta Strategy offers investors a practical way to participate in the Net Zero transition without sacrificing investment discipline. By combining intrinsic valuation, forward-looking climate analysis, and active stewardship, the Strategy aims to align capital with companies delivering real transition outcomes, at the right price.

As global investment in the transition accelerates, we believe this pragmatic approach will become increasingly important in closing the gap between sustainability goals and financial performance.


REFERENCES:
Greenhouse Gas Protocol, n.d., ‘Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Accounting and Reporting Standard’, GHG Protocol, viewed 19 December 2022, p.5.
IEA 2015, ‘Climate pledges for COP21 slow energy sector emissions growth dramatically’, IEA, viewed 19 December 2022.
IEA 2022, ’Database documentation’, IEA, viewed 19 December 2022.
IPCC 2018, ‘Global Warming of 1.5°C: An IPCC Special Report on the impacts of global warming of 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels and related global greenhouse gas emission pathways, in the context of strengthening the global response to the threat of climate change, sustainable development, and efforts’, IPCC, pp. 49-91, viewed 19 December 2022.
WRI 2020, ‘World Greenhouse Gas Emissions: 2016’, WRI, viewed 19 December 2022.
WMO 2025, ‘WMO Global Annual to Decadal Climate Update 2025-2029’, WMO, pp. 3-7, viewed 28 August 2025.
IMPORTANT INFORMATION:
This communication is prepared by Antipodes Partners Limited (‘Antipodes’) (ABN 29 602 042 035, AFSL 481 580) as the investment manager of the Antipodes Climate Delta Strategy (the ‘Strategy’) and is intended for wholesale clients only. Pinnacle Fund Services Limited (‘PFSL’) (ABN 29 082 494 362, AFSL 238371) is the product issuer of the Strategy and is a wholly owned subsidiary of Pinnacle Investment Management Group Limited (‘Pinnacle’) (ABN 22 100 325 184). Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance and the repayment of capital is not guaranteed. Any opinions and forecasts reflect the judgment and assumptions of Antipodes and its representatives based on information available as at the date of publication and may later change without notice. Whilst Antipodes, PFSL and Pinnacle believe the information contained in this communication is reliable, no warranty is given as to its accuracy, reliability or completeness and persons relying on this information do so at their own risk. To the extent permitted by law, Antipodes, PFSL and Pinnacle disclaim all liability to any person relying on the information contained in this communication in respect of any loss or damage (including consequential loss or damage), however caused, which may be suffered or arise directly or indirectly in respect of such information. Unauthorised use, copying, distribution, replication, posting, transmitting, publication, display, or reproduction in whole or in part of the information contained in this communication is prohibited without obtaining prior written permission from Antipodes.

Share:

More Posts

Now available on the ASX: the Antipodes Global SMID Active ETF (ASX:MIDS)

X